From Goodfellas
Johnny Dio's Prison Steak
- Servings
- 4
- Cuisine
- Italian-American
- Difficulty
- Easy

Ingredients
Method
- Salt the steaks generously and let them sit at room temperature for 20–30 minutes.
- Get a heavy pan smoking hot with the olive oil — no broiler needed, exactly as the joint was run.
- Sear the steaks 2–3 minutes a side as an initial estimate, adjusting for thickness. For the home method, check with a food thermometer in the thickest part, avoiding bone: each steak must reach at least 145°F (63°C) before removing it from the heat, then rest at least 3 minutes before serving. Keep the full five-minute rest in step 5. Time and colour are not the endpoint; follow the safe-temperature chart.
- In the last minute, drop in the butter and garlic and baste.
- Rest 5 minutes before serving. No sides needed beyond the pasta course that came before.
In the movie
Theatrical
- 01:21:09 Henry's prison narration continues past the pasta course — 'we had a pasta course, and then we had a meat or a fish' — with Johnny Dio pan-searing steaks in the cell with no broiler, cooking Henry's to a requested medium rare
Henry's prison narration doesn't stop at the pasta: "we had a pasta course, and then we had a meat or a fish." Johnny Dio does the meat with no broiler in the cell block, cooking everything in pans until the smell fills the joint and the guards can't stand it — and still turning out, by Henry's own account, a great steak. Ordering it medium rare, and getting it, is one more small proof of exactly how well-run this stretch of "prison" really was. This is a reconstruction of the plainest possible version of what Henry describes — the film narrates the method rather than publishing a recipe.
Serve when
Henry's 'medium rare' is the historical film request; serve after following the measured home method, right after the gravy course while Paulie's razor-thin garlic is still perfuming the cell block.
Before you start
A pan sear is only a few minutes a side, so have the steaks at room temperature and the pan smoking hot before the pasta course even finishes.
Cook-along start: ~1:20
Scene cue: The gravy course is cleared and Johnny Dio starts pan-searing steaks with no broiler in sight — 'How do you like yours?' 'Medium rare.' 'An aristocrat.' Bring the second course out right on that line.
Beyond the recipe
Watch & shop
Check the temperature
- Thermapen ONE Instant-read thermometer
- ThermoPop 2 Everyday instant-read thermometer
- ChefAlarm Leave-in probe thermometer with a timer and alarm
As an Amazon Associate, FlixNFood earns from qualifying purchases.
As an affiliate, FlixNFood may earn from qualifying purchases.