FlixNFood

From Waitress

I Hate My Husband Pie

dessert · Reconstructed

Servings
8
Cuisine
American diner
Difficulty
Medium
Preparation time
4 hours
I Hate My Husband Pie (AI-generated illustration)
AI-generated illustration. This image is not evidence that the recipe has been kitchen-tested.

Ingredients

  • For the bittersweet filling:
  • For the drowning caramel:

Method

Thick chocolate custard coating a whisk and holding broad tracks in a saucepan (AI-generated illustration)
Step 1: The pudding is thick and the chocolate is incorporated before the filling goes into the crust. AI-generated illustration.
  1. Make the pudding: whisk yolks, cornstarch, the scant sugar, and milk; cook until thick, then melt in the chocolate. Keep it defiantly bitter.
  2. Pour into the crust and chill until set, 4 hours.
  3. Make the caramel: melt the sugar to deep amber, then whisk in the butter, then the cream, then the salt. It sputters hard when the cream hits — stand back and use a long-handled whisk.
  4. Drown the pie — pour the caramel over the whole surface, letting it flood.
  5. Serve to whoever earned it. The name is a serving suggestion.

In the movie

Theatrical

  • 00:06:56 One of Jenna's invented, mood-named pies — recipe spoken aloud in her head as she bakes: unsweetened bittersweet chocolate pudding, drowned in caramel. The film's pies are her diary.

Jenna narrates her pies like diary entries — the film's signature device — and this is the most quoted one, the recipe delivered straight to camera in her head. Bitter base, sweet flood: the marriage, in dessert form.

Serve when

Serve it while narrating its recipe deadpan, as Jenna does: 'You make it with bittersweet chocolate and don't sweeten it. You make it into a pudding and drown it in caramel.'

Before you start

The pudding needs 4 hours to set before the caramel goes on — get it in the fridge well ahead of the movie.

Cook-along start: before the movie

Scene cue: Jenna's recipe voiceover, deadpan: bittersweet chocolate, unsweetened, made into a pudding and drowned in caramel. The film's pies are her diary, and this is the bitterest entry.

Beyond the recipe

Watch it made