FlixNFood

From Waitress

Marshmallow Mermaid Pie

dessert · Reconstructed

Servings
8
Cuisine
American diner
Difficulty
Medium
Preparation time
4 hours
Cooking time
8 min
Marshmallow Mermaid Pie (AI-generated illustration)
AI-generated illustration. This image is not evidence that the recipe has been kitchen-tested.

Ingredients

  • For the crust:

Method

  1. Blitz the grahams with the toasted coconut and butter; press into a pie dish and bake 8 minutes at 350°F. Cool.
  2. Melt the marshmallows with the milk over low heat; cool to room temperature.
  3. Fold in the whipped cream and most of the grated chocolate.
  4. Mound into the crust and chill 4 hours.
  5. Shower with the remaining chocolate. Serve to someone whose reaction you'd like to hear about later.
Graham cracker, toasted coconut and butter crumbs rest in the stopped food processor. (AI-generated illustration) A glass base presses coconut-graham crumbs into a pie dish before baking. (AI-generated illustration)
Step 1, before baking: Blitz the grahams, toasted coconut and butter (top), then press the crumbs into the pie dish (bottom). The processor is stopped in the first view; the glass base is one way to press the crumbs. Bake eight minutes at 350°F and cool before filling. AI-generated illustrations.
A spatula stirs marshmallows and milk as they melt before cooling. (AI-generated illustration) The listed whipped-cream component is ready before folding into the cooled marshmallow base. (AI-generated illustration) A spatula folds whipped cream and grated chocolate into the cooled marshmallow base. (AI-generated illustration)
Steps 2–3: Melt the marshmallows with milk over low heat (top), then cool the base to room temperature before folding. The separate whipped-cream component is shown in the middle; fold it and most of the grated chocolate into the cooled base (bottom). No extra cream or melted-chocolate filling is added. AI-generated illustrations.
The pale chocolate-flecked filling is mounded into the cooled crumb crust before chilling. (AI-generated illustration) A hand scatters the remaining grated chocolate over the pie after the written chill. (AI-generated illustration)
Steps 4–5: Mound the filling into the baked, cooled crust (top), then complete the four-hour fridge chill before scattering the remaining grated chocolate (bottom). The two views show before and after that chill. AI-generated illustrations.

In the movie

Theatrical

  • 00:24:04 The pie Jenna brings to her OB appointment — inherited by the new Dr. Pomatter, who reports back: 'that pie was biblically good.' A toasted-coconut, marshmallow-cream confection from Joe's Pie Diner's board of wonders.

The mermaid pie sets the whole affair in motion — a thank-you bake that gets a review so good it counts as flirting. This marshmallow-coconut pie is a home reconstruction. The linked Babish feature recreates other Waitress pies, not this one.

Serve when

Serve it to your doctor if you must — this is the pie Dr. Pomatter calls 'biblically good.'

Before you start

Bake the crust, melt the marshmallow, then give it a full 4 hours in the fridge to set before serving — start it well before the movie.

Cook-along start: before the movie

Scene cue: The pie that starts the whole affair — Jenna's thank-you bake to her OB, and Dr. Pomatter's verdict comes back: 'that pie was biblically good.'

Beyond the recipe

Watch it made