FlixNFood

From It's Complicated

Jane's Three Pies: Apple, Blueberry & Plum

dessert · Reconstructed

Servings
24
Cuisine
American
Difficulty
Medium
Preparation time
1 hour
Jane's Three Pies: Apple, Blueberry & Plum (AI-generated illustration)
AI-generated illustration. This image is not evidence that the recipe has been kitchen-tested.

Ingredients

  • For one double pie crust (make three batches):
  • For the apple filling:
  • For the blueberry filling:
  • For the plum filling:

Method

  1. For each crust, pulse the flour, salt, and sugar together, then cut in the cold butter until it's pea-sized. Add ice water a tablespoon at a time until the dough just holds together. Divide in two, flatten into discs, and chill at least an hour.
  2. For each filling, toss the fruit with its sugar, thickener, spice, and lemon juice (as listed) and let it sit 15 minutes to draw out some juice.
  3. Roll out a bottom crust for each pie and fit it into a 9-inch pie dish. Fill with the corresponding fruit mixture.
  4. Roll out the top crusts — lattice, full round with vents, or a mix — and seal the edges of each pie.
  5. Bake all three at 375°F for 45–55 minutes, until the crusts are deep golden and the fillings bubble visibly through the vents. Tent with foil partway through if the crust is browning too fast.
  6. Cool at least 2 hours before slicing so the fillings set.
Cold butter pieces distributed through flour beside a pastry blender.
Within step 1: Cut the cold butter into the flour mixture before adding the ice water. AI-generated illustration.

Substitutions

  • Butter crust: a half-butter, half-shortening crust holds its shape a little better for transport, if you're carrying all three across town like Jane does.

In the movie

Theatrical

  • ~00:42:30 Jane arrives at a friend's living room with "three beautiful homemade pies" — apple, blueberry, and plum — right before she confesses she's having an affair

Jane shows up to a friends' gathering with all three pies stacked in her arms, and the reaction — "Three pies?! This is a feast!" — is really about what the pies signal: she's been baking nonstop, riding an energy she can't quite explain yet, and the pies are the setup for the scene where she tells her friends why. It's the film's one moment of pure excess in the kitchen, three whole pies for an evening of wine and gossip, and it works because it's clearly more than anyone needed.

Serve when

Jane walks into the middle of a girls' night carrying all three pies at once, and someone immediately calls it a feast.

As an Amazon Associate, FlixNFood earns from qualifying purchases.